I don’t usually watch much TV… I know it’s surprising,
somebody with the massive absence of a social life not watching TV but it’s
true. In between masturbation cycles, random arguments and crying myself to
sleep, I generally don’t watch very much. That’s not to say I don’t watch any
TV at all though. I am a massive fan of House – having watched it since the
beginning – and will watch the odd episode of whatever else may be on at the
time. There’s one thing I do a lot though, and that’s read. It’s true, apart
from touching myself and planning world domination, I read a hell of a lot, and
have recently finished the first book in George R.R. Martin’s epic fantasy A
Song of Ice and Fire series, A Game of Thrones from which the show took its
name (book review imminent). I was taken in by the book in a way I cannot properly
explain, but the characters, the setting, the story and everything else sunk
its hooks into me and wouldn’t let me go, so I decided to give the show a look
and watched it at the same pace as I was reading the book.
Book to TV adaptations are nothing new, shows such as Dexter
and True Blood have built up cult followings, but the Song of Ice and Fire
books are something totally different. They are truly epic novels and there was
likely going to be significant difficulty in adapting these novels for the
small screen, even being made for HBO, an adaptation that kept loyal to the
original material would have been an immense task. Any reasonable person would
understand that there were going to have to be changes made from the books in
the process of bringing it to TV, but these changes did nothing to change my
original views of the book and may have actually improved upon the story from
the novel at certain points.
“Kings and queens,
knights and renegades, liars, lords and honest men… all will play the Game of
Thrones”
The begins with Lord Eddard Stark, Lord of the North who is
invited to become the Hand of the King to his long time friend, King Robert
Baratheon, following the death of the previous Hand, Jon Arryn. Lord Eddard a
man of immense honour, loves his family deeply, but shamed himself many years
ago when he fathered a bastard child, Jon Snow. While he is serving as the
King’s hand, Lord Eddard begins to grow suspicious about the death of Jon Arryn
and begins to investigate the crime. As he does so he comes to discover more
than he bargained for, which leads to revelations of treason, murder and
incest. Back in Winterfell, Lord Eddard’s son, Bran an enthusiastic climber,
discovers the Queen and her brother, the Kingslayer, Jaime Lannister having sex.
Jaime pushes Bran from the window, intending to kill him, yet he survives, but
is crippled. It is discovered, after an additional attempt to kill the child by
a hired assassin, the Houses of Lannister and Stark clash in what is both a war
of honour and family. An additional story, taking place alongside but totally
separate from it is that of Daenerys Targaryen, heiress to the Targaryen
throne, the family which was overthrown by Robert Baratheon to take the throne,
forcing the surviving members of the Targaryen family, Daenerys and her
brother, Viserys into exile. She has been arranged to marry the Dothraki king,
Khal Drogo, by her brother Viserys in exchange that he shall receive an army
with which he may reclaim his rightful place as the King. During her time as
Khaleesi, Dany grows stronger and more confident as she realises that she has
the blood of the dragon within her.
I don’t want to give too much away at the risk of spoiling
the story for those who have not read the books, or have had the pleasure of
watching the show, so I shall say no more on the story itself. The first season
I have found to remain largely loyal to the first book in the series by
focusing on the POV characters in the book; Lord Eddard, Catelyn Stark, Sansa
Stark, Arya Stark, Bran Stark, Tyrion Lannister, Jon Snow and Daenerys
Targaryen. There were additional scenes created which weren’t a part of the
actual book, yet these worked well in fleshing out the non-POV characters and
tying certain scenes together so that the book may work just as well on screen.
While each actor worked superbly in his or her respective roles, special
mention goes to Sean Bean who played Eddard “Ned” Stark and Peter Dinklage as
the “Imp”, Tyrion Lannister. Bean’s portrayal as Eddard Stark is exactly how
you’d expect him to be if the character were real, his honour and his love and
compassion come across superbly as he delivers a character most would want as
their father, or at least a close relative. Dinklage’s portrayal as the “Imp”
Tyrion Lannister has won him significant
mainstream recognition, and rightly so. Like Bean, his character is exactly
how the reader of the books would imagine him to be in real life in both his
mannerisms and his voice. It’s said “A Lannister always pays his debts”, but
where the circumstances will benefit Tyrion, he will pay any price to get you
on his side and to do what he wants. This does not mean he is cold and
uncaring. We come to know that Tyrion has had a horrid past, and with his
dwarfism, he is looked down upon – both literally and figuratively – and will
never amount to anything significant and this in many ways, warrants his close
and growing friendship with Ned Stark’s bastard, Jon Snow.
Such an adaptation is an ambitious project, even for HBO but
there are times where the show does fall short of what one would expect. An
example of this would be the scale of the battles which take place in the book
that are either scaled down for the sake of the show or don’t take place at
all. For budgetary reasons, one can sort of understand why that would be the
case, yet there are some instances during which the battles, or a characters
involvement in them I felt to be crucial to the way in which that character
appeared. An example of this is late in the book and series where Tyrion is
reunited with his father after escaping Lady Catelyn’s capture following
accusations that he was involved in the attempt on her son Bran’s life. Upon
his reunion, Tyrion is told he must lead his men into battle against an army of
the North. In the book, there are a few instances where Tyrion is involved in
direct fighting, actually bringing down a knight. In the show, however, Tyrion
is knocked down by an enthusiastic stampede of his own men and is knocked out,
only waking when the battle is over. The scene in the book portrays Tyrion as a
quick thinker who perhaps may be tougher than he appears, yet the show portrays
the dwarf as clumsy and overly weak by being taken down in such a way. While I
understand that earlier in the season Tyrion is involved in some fighting, this
scene stood out as unnecessarily and damagingly altered, though knowing George
R.R. Martin’s close involvement in the show, such changes are forgivable. The
beautiful and sometimes expansive sets are too something with which HBO should
have immense pride in achieving. While the channel is known for its big budget TV shows,
one has to ask whether they have broken a record in its competent adaptation of
an epic novel into an epic television series.
Seriously, I cannot recommend this enough, though I would
recommend that you pick the book up first. There are a lot of characters to get
to know in the series, and being familiar with them by reading the books first
will help with that and prevent you from getting lost. George R.R. Martin’s
involvement in the show is undoubtedly one of the primary reasons David Benioff and D.B. Weiss have kept the
show to such a high quality. Martin is one of our finest fictional writers, and
this show is one of the finest television adaptations of a fictional novel
series I have ever had the pleasure of viewing. Season 1 is out on Blu-Ray
and DVD
now, which I’d strongly urge you all to go out and buy.




